I’ve always loved the idea of starting the day with something that feels like a little celebration. That’s why these birthday cake overnight oats are one of my favorite breakfasts.

These Birthday Cake Overnight Oats taste like a sweet treat but still give you all the goodness of whole oats, protein, and simple ingredients you probably already have. Just mix, chill, and wake up to a creamy, colorful jar that kids love.

• Save

If you’re looking for things to do with oats beyond the usual, this recipe hits it: cake overnight oats, birthday cake oatmeal, and even healthy birthday breakfast ideas for kids all in one. It’s a simple way to turn your oats into a birthday overnight oats treat that’s just as special as a real cake—but way easier.

In this recipe, I’ll show you how I make my birthday cake overnight oats, what gives them that classic birthday taste, and how you can tweak them for your own style.

For More Fun Overnight Oats Recipes, Check Out More

Maple Pecan Overnight Oats

Brown sugar Apple Cinnamon Streusel Overnight Oats (chia seed)

Overnight Peach Cobbler Oatmeal

Healthy Carrot Cheese Cake Overnight Oats

Substitutes for Almond Butter

Almond butter adds creaminess and a nutty flavor, but you don’t have to skip the recipe if your pantry is bare. 

Peanut butter is the most common swap and gives the oats a stronger, slightly salty flavor that pairs well with sprinkles and maple syrup. 

Cashew butter is another smooth option if you want something milder. If you’re avoiding nuts, sunflower seed butter works well and keeps the texture creamy without changing the taste too much.

For those who don’t want any nut or seed butters, plain Greek yogurt can add thickness and protein while still keeping the oats soft. The key is to include something that blends well and helps hold the oats together. That way, you keep the rich, birthday-cake feel, even with a different base ingredient.

Tool Requirements

• A whisk helps break up the Greek yogurt and distribute the chia seeds evenly throughout the mixture.
• Measuring cups and spoons ensure the right balance of ingredients for optimal pudding consistency. 
• Overnight Oats Containers with Lids and Spoons

Nutrition Snapshot

• Calories: ~280 kcal
• Protein: ~20–22 g
• Carbohydrates: ~39–41 g
• Dietary Fiber: ~5–6 g
• Total Fat: ~5 g
• Saturated Fat: ~1.5 g
• Sugars: ~5–9 g (depending on added sweetener)
• Sodium: ~130–160 mg

This recipe gives you a solid protein boost, which helps keep you full for longer and makes it a great breakfast choice if you don’t want to snack too soon after eating. 

The carbs and sugar are moderate, so while it tastes fun and dessert-like, it isn’t overloaded with sweetness. The fat content stays on the lower side, which works well if you’re limiting rich ingredients, but you can always add extra nut butter for more healthy fats.

How to Serve It Fun

Birthday Cake Overnight Oats aren’t just about taste. They can look just as fun as the name suggests. A few simple touches can turn your oats from just breakfast into something that feels special.

Jar It Up

Use clear glass jars so the sprinkles and creamy layers show through. It instantly feels more festive.

Top It Like a Cake

Add a swirl of coconut whipped cream and a few extra sprinkles on top. It’s a small detail that makes it feel like a real dessert.

Add Color

Mix in fresh berries or sliced fruit for natural pops of color against the oats

Serve With a Candle

If it’s a birthday, stick in a small candle before serving. It makes the moment playful and memorable.

Even if it’s just a regular morning, presenting your oats this way can make breakfast feel like a mini celebration.

• Save

Coconut Milk Twist

Switching the almond milk for coconut milk gives your birthday cake oats a rich, tropical flavor that changes the whole experience. Coconut milk is naturally creamier and adds a subtle sweetness that pairs perfectly with sprinkles and vanilla extract. Use full-fat coconut milk if you want your oats to feel thick, almost pudding-like, or go with the lighter version for a softer, more refreshing texture.

The oats absorb the coconut flavor overnight, so every spoonful has a faint island vibe without overpowering the cake batter taste. If you enjoy extra coconut, top the finished oats with shredded coconut flakes or toasted coconut chips for crunch. 

This swap also makes the recipe dairy-free and works well for anyone avoiding nut milks. It’s a simple ingredient change, but it transforms the final dish into something that feels like birthday cake with a tropical twist.

How do You Keep It Creamy Overnight?

The texture makes or breaks overnight oats. If they end up dry or clumpy, they won’t feel like a treat. To keep them creamy, always start with enough liquid. A good rule is about one part oats to two parts milk.

Almond milk keeps it light, but oat milk or regular dairy milk gives extra creaminess. Chia seeds and flaxseed also help. They soak up liquid and create a pudding-like texture. Don’t forget to stir well before chilling, because dry oats on the bottom will stay hard.  

Covering the bowl or jar tightly also matters since it locks in moisture. If your oats feel too thick in the morning, just stir in a splash of extra milk until they reach the texture you like. With these small tricks, you’ll wake up to oats that feel rich and creamy every time.

Can You Pack Them for On-the-Go?

Overnight oats are perfect for busy mornings, and birthday cake oats are no exception. With a few simple steps, you can prep them ahead and enjoy a quick, tasty breakfast anytime:

• Prepare oats in a portable, leak-proof jar or container (glass mason jars look great).
• Keep toppings like sprinkles or berries separate to stay fresh.
• Add whipped cream at home or use a spoonful of yogurt for on-the-go.
• Store in the fridge for 3–4 days for grab-and-go breakfasts or snacks.

Can I Bake Them Instead?

Sometimes cold oats aren’t what you’re craving, especially on a chilly morning. The good news is you can easily turn your birthday cake overnight oats into baked oats. It’s the same ingredients, but instead of resting in the fridge, they go in the oven for a warm, cake-like breakfast.

Here’s the step-by-step process:

Step 1: Mix your ingredients

In a large bowl, stir together your oats, chia seeds, flaxseed, almond milk, nut butter, sweetener, and extracts. Mix well so the oats are fully coated and the nut butter blends in smoothly.

Step 2: Prepare your baking dish

Lightly grease a small baking dish or individual ramekins with a little oil or butter. This prevents sticking and makes it easier to scoop out later.

Step 3: Pour and spread the mixture

Transfer the oat mixture into the prepared dish. Use a spoon to spread it out evenly so it bakes consistently.

Step 4: Bake the oats

Place the dish in a preheated oven at 350°F (175°C). Bake for 25–30 minutes, or until the top is golden and the center looks set.

Step 5: Add sprinkles the right way

You can fold sprinkles into the batter before baking, but keep in mind that some colors may fade or bleed slightly when exposed to heat.

Step 6: Cool briefly before serving

Let the baked oats rest for about 5 minutes so they set a little more and are easier to slice.

Step 7: Add your toppings

Finish with a dollop of yogurt, a swirl of whipped cream, fresh berries, or extra sprinkles to make it feel like a true birthday treat.

Ice Cream Oats – Will It Work?

Birthday cake oats are already creamy, but you can take them a step further and make them feel like dessert straight from the freezer. Once your oats have chilled and set in the fridge overnight, scoop them into a freezer-safe container. Let them firm up for 1–2 hours until they reach a thicker, ice cream-like consistency. 

To keep them smooth, stir the oats halfway through freezing so they don’t get icy. When ready to eat, add toppings that match the frozen treat vibe, extra sprinkles, coconut whipped cream, or even a drizzle of melted chocolate. The texture will be denser than typical ice cream but still cold and satisfying.

It’s a fun way to eat oats on a hot day, and kids especially love it. Just remember not to freeze them too long, or they’ll harden completely.